Depression runs in the family, particularly for the women in my family. My mother succumbed to severe gloom after three babies in three years. (Who wouldn’t?) After therapy, bulimia, and a divorce, she still had many hard years ahead of her. My dad’s mother also wrestled with depression. A stay-at-home mom with four children, I can imagine life was not always blooming lilacs.
As a newlywed, I realized from my family history that staying at home to parent full-time might not be emotionally/mentally healthy for me or my future kids. But I determined to give it my best shot.
When pretty little package #1 arrived, I found myself struggling to cope. I had just finished my masters in English, and the pace change from full-time grad student to full-time mom just about turned my soul to jello. In an oven.
I felt scooped out, drained, bored, goal hungry, and sad, sad, sad.
When we found out pretty little package #2 was on her way, we were in an airport with our (ehem) six-month-old daughter. Surprise! After I finished a good cry, we ate gooey cinnamon rolls to celebrate.
With two littles, I was more grateful than ever to have continued my education. Having a masters in English qualifies me to teach freshman-level composition courses at colleges and universities, and this outlet has saved me. (I don’t use the word “saved” lightly here.) Even teaching a course once a week has been enough to stimulate some of those brain cells in need of dopamine.
My very worst months are those when I don’t have any professional outlet (summer time or between jobs). During those months, I do my best to establish a daily routine that keeps me and my kids upbeat. For example, we attend the local library’s story time as if it were a second religion. Praise be to cheery children’s librarians!
I also try to write. Whether I’m working part-time or not, consistent writing has been like a tropical breeze in the Artic.
I started writing poetry before I had kids and was struggling with infertility. (Yes, you read that correctly, despite the precedent information on my reproductive history). Poetry became increasingly important as I grappled with the strong emotions of being a mother. Writing poetry helped me navigate days when, within minutes, my feelings would swing between euphoric and frighteningly negative.
I still identify as a novice poet. I have so much to learn, but in ways I’m (gulp) grateful for my domestic experience because of the opportunity I have to explore creative writing.
Here is a poem I wrote about a SAHM and creating space for oneself through writing. A version of this poem was originally published by Flutter Press in my chapbook Mothering:
Stay-At-Home Room
She knows the feel
of cold water and rice grains
against her skin
as her hand sweeps
down-the-drain food.
She knows the sound
of a thousand granules
of spilled yeast
plinking on the countertop,
or she would
if she could hear them
over the dishwasher
and dryer and children,
stay-at-home sounds.
She knows how to tear
a crisp wedge of lettuce
into pieces the size
of her children’s small mouths,
the way one might break
bread, the way she breaks
herself into pieces
small enough to eat,
flesh-and-blood meal.
She knows the monotonous music
of Twinkle, Twinkle,
and the ABCs,
and Baa, Baa, Black Sheep,
Mozart recycled,
same-old-tune songs.
To staunch the dark,
she creates something new,
calls it a poem,
and with words for walls
conceives a room
filled with rich light
illuminating her hands,
her head, her heart,
good-as-gold life.
-Submitted by Dayna.
See all the Parenthood Juggle guest posts here. Go here for this guest post invitation. Submissions should be sent to guestposts@dovesandserpents.org (please see our guest post guide).
Dayna, I just wrote an essay for Holly Welker’s book on marriage. I hope you did, too. When you read mine, you’ll see we have a lot more in common than just poetry. Thanks for sharing.
Dearest Dayna. I’m sure I’m not aware of the whole roller coaster of your life, but what I see, I love. Your poetry is a blessing to you and to me, and to so many others. I’m grateful that you need to write . . . and that you can, with such insight. I have never felt the darkness but my “good-as-gold life” is brighter because of you.
Ah, Norma, you’re so sweet. I can always expect to hear kind words from you.
Did you really never experience any kind of depression with your seven little people at home? I think you are absolutely amazing!
Marilyn, I DID write an essay/poem for Holly. I’m excited to read your essay.
I think more stay-at-home moms wrestle with depression than is generally acknowledged. Maybe stay-at-home dads suffer from depression, too, although there probably isn’t as much data available.
What is it about being a SAHM, particularly an LDS SAHM, that makes it difficult to discuss depression, I wonder?
SAHMs don’t feel comfortable discussing depression because being a stay-at-home-mom is supposed to be the fulfillment of their divine role in life. That’s serious business. When you are told that you are MADE/DESIGNED to do something (be a mother) and that you are supposed to love it and that it’s the most important thing you’ll ever do and everything else pales in comparison, it’s pretty tough to own up to the fact that you don’t enjoy it or that it sucks your soul or, shoot, even that it makes you miserable. And no, it’s not JUST Mormon SAHMs, but Mormon SAHMs have it worse, in my opinion, because it’s not just a societal/cultural expectation or tradition; it’s considered a divine mandate. It’s one thing to cast aside a cultural tradition or stereotype or expectation; quite another to cast aside your reason for existence, as per God.
I think you are spot on, Heather. It is one thing to let down your cultural tradition, but to feel like you are falling short of your divine potential by not being happy . . . well, that just adds to the depression, doesn’t it? It’s a vicious cycle.
Exactly.
Isn’t it crazy how very desperately we want them and how very much it changes our life to have them. My mom used to say that she worked because her self esteem suffered at home. At work she WAS somebody. People listened to her, looked up to her even……
I was an overworked and over tired mom too. I have many, many regrets- all the “should haves and could haves, but didn’t”….. I never measured up to all the perfect women with perfect lives and perfect houses (okay… clean houses)…… I never WAS anybody…. I had to find ways to feel important… painting, sewing, teaching painting lessons, teaching sewing and quilting lessons…. getting published, people buying my creations…. hiring me to do artful projects for them….. while changing diapers, running a chauffeur service to soccer, basketball, dance, scouts, singing lessons…. Feeling overwhelmed and under-appreciated… always……
I baked bread to make the budget go farther… I wept when I found that my poor boy had been wearing shoes two sizes too small for months because we couldn’t afford more yet….. I mourned that they grew up too fast….
and……..
I hurt desperately that they have, indeed, left the nest…. and left my house hollow and empty…. this old mother still lives in the shoes…. but now… her children are grown and she, again…. doesn’t know what to do…..
BUT- has joy in knowing that her grandchildren have a better mother than what she ever was or could have been….
Judy, I am AMAZED at how much I wanted children, but then how hard it has been to actually PARENT them. It makes current bouts of depression even more frustrating. I tell myself, wait, you WANTED this. You went on meds and saw an infertility doctor so you could have these bundles in your life. It’s crazy-making stuff. I do feel a lot better when I have some part-time work as an outlet. I feel like I am a better mom and am much, much happier overall.
I agree that having an outlet is super important. It gives us balance. It is like coming up for air and taking huge gulps after diving down a little too deep….
It is the balance that I found/find tricky. I loved being a mom. I loved my little brood. I also was depressed and cranky a lot. I resented having no sleep. I resented the constant squabbles in that a house full of boys, so many, many boys…. I resented that my husband often took me for granted, my role for granted, (my rolls too, for that matter….) I often felt the four walls closing in and the messes never ending. I was cranky and grouchy far too often….
And I got my degree with those seven little people at home because I needed to know that I was someone. I needed to know that I had value. I wasn’t always sure of that. I always succeeded at school. I felt smart there. Getting A’s meant that someone else knew that I was smart. That grade proved it somehow.
I needed to show my kids that education was important. I needed them to see that you never give up, that being a lifelong learner was important.
When I started teaching I was ecstatic. I loved it. I was so excited to share my day with…… children. (haha) I was so excited to plan and provide them with the most wonderful learning experiences. It was great….. for a few years.
Then, somehow….. the classroom filled with more and more children with terrible problems. Problems they didn’t ask for but definitely couldn’t escape from…. and …. I started feeling trapped again…. only, instead of being trapped at home…. it was trapped at work…..
So I got my master’s in hope of filling that cup again, finding that joy again…. Teaching all day and taking night classes to get that degree…..
and I am happy I did. I am happy to have it…. for myself… for accomplishing my goal…..
but….
now I long for my home life again….. I long for painting and sewing a bit…. I long for the solitude of my four walls…. the pleasures of baking bread again…….
Where is the balance???? I just can’t seem to find it.
I guess that is where I am in life. Kind of like running up and down the teeter totter………
I am glad you are learning about finding that balance much sooner than I did. I am glad you recognize the difficulties and also feel the joy in those two darling girlies.
Judy, I can absolutely imagine myself down the road a few years, deep into a profession, and longing for home life again. I can imagine it, but it doesn’t make now any easier, if you know what I mean. BALANCE, yes. Maybe we all need to be working part-time ;)
Thank you for sharing this and for being so honest about your feelings and experience. I used to write poetry to deal with depression in high school, and I have recently rediscovered it as I’ve been healing from the underlying causes of that depression, as well as dealing with infertility and then a miscarriage. It helps. Not sure how, but it does. Anyway, I appreciate you sharing because sometimes one person sharing their feelings opens up space for others to share and feel understood.
Kristen, have you heard of scriptotherapy? James Pennebaker has published several studies on the link between writing and healing. I think he mostly deals with journaling, though, not creative writing.
Dayna, I love this. Thank you for being such an inspiration to me. You are so very talented. Love you!
Holls, you are absolutely an inspiration to me, too. Love you!
Dayn, I feel the sadness emanating from your words and I admit there are times I have felt the same, but never have I really thought about it from the same perspective. You have lived an amazing and fulfilling life from my point of view. You have traveled the world, lived in new and exciting places, and have achieved so much with your education and writing talents. I sometimes feel stuck without any hope of there being an escape, many of my dreams and aspirations are put on hold and probably permanently for the better of my family. I can’t justify the funds to fulfill them when they would have to sacrifice so much. My depression has been an unwanted partner in my life ever since I can remember. I have never equated it with being a mother though, I think whether or not my children were a part of my life, the depression would be there regardless, like an appendage I can’t amputate, or a diseased vital organ that I must keep in check or the disease will spread throughout my entire body and take over my thoughts. There have been many times I was on the verge of being a danger to myself and it was scary. I too have found (just in the last few years) that investing in myself and accomplishing goals (whether they be physical, academic, project, or something else) I am able to ward off the worst of the overwhelming sadness that can seem debilitating if I’m unsuccessful.
I think there are misconceptions about motherhood, that many women believe they should feel accomplished by having children, what their children do, how their children behave, and they live vicariously through their children. That is a recipe for depression isn’t it? If a woman believes having children is the key to happiness and then finds afterwards that she isn’t happy JUST because of her children, she will feel guilty and that there is something wrong with her as she looks around at the other women that probably feel the same but are putting on a happy face so no one will know. Your children are your family, and just as any other family member they are there for you just as you are there for them. Someday they won’t need you so desperately and maybe you will be able to feel more of a symbiotic relationship with them, especially when they are grown and gone.
Has depression only affected you since you became a mother? Do you feel that it wouldn’t be such an issue for you if you if had never been able to have children? I will always remember how Dad used to tell us “You choose how you feel.” I have only understood what he meant by that more and more over the years. My children do not make me happy. My husband does not make me happy. My father, my sister, my friend, my house, my car, my cell phone…. none of them MAKE me happy. When I am happy, it’s because I choose to be happy and I’m choosing to see the positive things in my life at that moment. Knowing this has helped me a lot, I can’t depend on anyone else to help me when I feel sad, it’s not fair to them. I have learned that the hard way too. I put too much pressure on Shawn to make sure I felt good about myself and it almost ruined our relationship.
I didn’t mean to preach here, I am not trying to fix anything… only to blab about what I have learned and hope you find something helpful or comforting in it. I love you, and I think you are the best sister ever. I can’t wait to see you again.
Clare, I don’t know if you’re Mormon or not, but from my perspective–as a Mormon–the insane focus, beginning at age 12–on getting married helps facilitate this idea that other people make us happy and that other people are required to “complete” women. Of course, this comes from Hollywood as well (“You complete me”). I saw a meme going around the other day that said, “Be with [but ‘with’ was scratched out] someone that makes you happy,’ so it just reads, “Be someone that makes you happy.”
I printed it out and put it on my girls’ bathroom mirrors. So let’s stop asking girls to make lists of the characteristics they want in a future husband. Let’s start talking to them about what kind of PEOPLE they want to become, what kinds of qualities they want to develop, what kinds of skills they want to learn, etc.–rather than focusing on how they’re going to facilitate other people’s lives.
It’s a dangerous, dreaded focus.
Thanks for this, Clare. We haven’t really talked about this much lately, have we? I didn’t realize that you’ve been struggling with depression, too, although that makes sense given our family history.
I think choosing how we feel is a powerful concept, but sometimes people have something going on that is chemical or hormonal. I have resisted getting on any kind of medication, although I know several SAHMs that are on meds. When I was in Ireland, I took a kind of birth control pill to lessen my cramps, and it made my mood even out. I didn’t have low lows or high highs-I was sort of living life calmly happy, if that makes sense.
Would I be depressed if I didn’t have kids? Good question. I remember feeling it on my mission. I’m sure I would be a basket case if I didn’t have kids because I feel like I came close to crazy when we were trying with no results. So, good point. Even if I didn’t have kids, I would probably be struggling.
On a related topic, I’m so stinking proud of all that you’ve accomplished in recent years. You are a role model for me, and for your kids, too.
Clare- I loved reading your comment. It made me fill up with tears. So eloquent, touching and full of wisdom. I often forget that it is up to me to choose how I will feel. Sometimes I don’t feel capable of making that happen. Sometimes I feel like it happens effortlessly…. crazy!
I loved how you poured out your feelings to Dayna from your heart. You are gifted with words just as she is. I love her just as you love her. She is priceless.
Heather- I liked that saying- the edited one- “Be someone who makes you happy.”…..
I think it could serve us all well.
I have a different concept than yours about the being Mormon and the notion of other people making us happy. I never was taught that idea coming from the church.
I did learn, however, that serving others, focusing on helping others, helps lift our moods and make us feel productive.
Again- I think that brings us back to the idea choice- choosing to help others, choosing to be happy.
Well yes, I agree with you on the service aspect. That’s definitely true.
I’m just coming at it from the standpoint of a mother of two daughters (ages 13 and 16). Such a drastic shift occurs when they turn 12 and go into YW. You go from talking about basic gospel principles (love, faith, service, etc.) to talking about marriage, marriage, your divine role as a woman, marriage, chastity, modesty, marriage, motherhood, chastity, modesty, rinse and repeat.
My daughters aren’t thinking about marriage, at all–which is at it should be. So I see that focus as being misguided and potentially very damaging. I’m not suggesting that replacing it with a selfish focus is the way to go! Just that all the focus on marriage as being your ticket to happiness is, well, not good (for lack of a better word).
Heather- thanks for the clarification. I see what you are saying and agree that marriage is not a ticket to happiness. My daughter is in YW too and what I see there for her is the idea of preparing to be WORTHY of a temple marriage when that time comes. That when she chooses to date, to choose wisely and stay clean. I see that as a continuation of the theme of ‘making good choices is good for the individual’ and their own happiness.
I think this is taught in YW because, ultimately, many girls go on to choose a husband and get married. That is not a bad thing. The ‘danger’ comes from thinking that the marriage itself is the arrival of happiness. We all know it is not. Marriage is hard, hard, hard. The marriage ceremony is not the end, but rather, the beginning of new challenges, a new learning time. Choosing unwisely is the source of unhappiness for many. I think that is why they start talking to the girls about this in YW immediately when they arrive.
My mom married a non-member. I heard her sobs into the dishwater. I heard her sobs behind the closed doors. I heard her sobs as we drove down the street in the car…… She was very unhappy at the basic differences they had. She loved him intensely. She would have no one talk badly about him. But…. he did not allow the children to be raised in the church. We were his children too….
She would talk to me constantly about choice and the importance of choosing someone who believed in the same things that I did. While she did not indicate that marriage and children would bring me happiness, she did indicate that I could be happier than she was if I made choices that would bring me less grief. It pained her greatly to know that this wonderful man, who she dearly, dearly loved- would not be hers forever.
When I grew up, I chose to be baptized- I was 16. When I grew up, I chose to do seminary as home study. (It was not available in other ways where I lived.) When I grew up, I chose to be married in the temple…. and I am glad to have made those choices…. I am glad for YW leaders who came over to chat with me privately about what to expect in the temple and what I needed to do to go there. I am also grateful that they did not misinform me with notions that my husband would bring me happiness, but rather, my decisions that would take me on the path to happiness.
I still have to work on staying on the happiness path. I still struggle- like most women- to focus on the good in my life. I can get swallowed up in misery and struggle to come up for a breath of happiness at times. We have hormones to compete with. We have husbands, children, family, neighbors, jobs, life circumstances, burnt dinners, pets who make messes… etc. etc. etc. that can irritate us on a whim……
but the saying goes, when life gives you lemons….. (you know the rest)….. sometimes we might feel that we live in a grove of lemon trees…… but then…. wouldn’t that be fragrant!
It sounds as if you are a wonderful mother who loves her daughters dearly and wants the best for them. Kudos to you for being there for them and guiding them with wisdom.
Dayna, you are right, it is a chemical and hormonal imbalance that really can’t be controlled by thoughts alone. Thoughts can do little more than help get us through the worst moments. I know there are days it doesn’t work. I have days when I feel so empty that absolutely nothing holds meaning to me… I feel like I could cry all day because happiness is so impossibly out of my reach. I get so frustrated because I know in my head what is going on. There is no precipitating event or hurt feelings… no reason for me to feel so absolutely worthless and I can hardly stand to look at my reflection in the mirror. I hate those days.
I do know that doing something physical like running or lifting weights as regularly as possible helps even things out for me. It is not a cure, I just know when I haven’t done anything in awhile I can tell by the worsening in my self-esteem and my overall mood. Many anti-depressant medications are working on increasing the amount of available serotonin which is naturally increased when you exercise, so it makes sense that it would help a little.
I definitely believe that what might work for one person will not work for another, but what matters is that there are ways to cope. I enjoy having a night out and going out for an hour or so with a friend, going to the gym alone, losing myself in word games (wink wink) and just allowing myself some simple pleasures.
You are one of the smartest people I know, and of course one of the funniest and most fun to be around. Love you!
Clare Bear, you’re awesome. I should be exercising more. That does always help me feel better. Fortunately, the weather grows nicer by the day, allowing for more outdoor activity.
love.lovelovelove. I’m so excited you’ve moved into my corner of the world. This poem is really a wonderful piece.
Thanks, Lara! I’m excited to be here, and I’m glad you’re here. We DO need to get together and talk poetry!