This week I found myself in that place Tinkerbell is so fond of — the place between asleep and awake. I opened my eyes from an awkward catnap on the I-80 in Nevada, and for a few brief moments I forgot which Honda I was waking in. It wasn’t the big blue Honda Odyssey of my current reality — stuffed to the brim with three kids and all that we needed for our trip to Utah this week. Rather, it was my red Honda CRX from my college days with my new husband at the wheel, and every inch of the hatch-back and the top of the roof rack stuffed sky-high with wedding gifts and the remnants of my childhood. (That poor car never drove quite the same again.)
When talking about personal spiritual evolution and religious education, it’s often noted that you can’t go back to unlearn what you now know. Yet in that moment of perceiving my world through the eyes of 1993, I was able to do just that. For a brief ten seconds, I was an optimistic, newly-married, twenty-one year old believer on her way back to BYU to give this Mormon lifestyle my best try. That version of me was wise and naive at the same time. I was hopeful, faithful and relieved to be on what I perceived as the right track in life. I knew there was an ultimate truth for every question in life, if I could just figure it all out. In short, I had a different mind — a mind that thought different thoughts, that questioned within a different framework, and attached itself to certain comfortable beliefs. And going back to THAT mind, even for ten seconds, was extremely unsettling.
I would do many things differently in my life if I was to live it again, but for the most part, I live regret-free. So surprisingly, as I shifted back into to my 2011 reality, I was overwhelmed with feelings of nostalgia and missing the person I once was, the mind that I once lived with. It was simpler then and life was much more innocent. I was just a young kid jumping into the arms of someone I loved, committing to be faithful to so many things. And, at twenty-one years old I knew that out of everything, I was capable of being faithful. What I didn’t realize was the shape that my faithfulness would take. Time has taught me that I am more faithful to honesty and answering big questions than I am to the Mormon tradition. I am more faithful to Dan the human being than I am to the institution of marriage.
If someone told me back then that my parents would soon be divorced, my father would remarry a woman he met on the internet, my mother would leave the church, marry the PE teacher from high school and that he would die from Alzheimers, that stable members of our family would go through periods of dark depression, joblessness, loneliness, anxiety, alcoholism, cancer scares, surgeries, early death, and gender confusion, I’m not sure I would have believed it. Had I known that I would experience depression, that I would stew in moments of loathing motherhood, periods of poverty, and that I would question every spiritual experience of my life up until that point – had I foreseen that in 2011, I would be more Buddhist than Mormon — I may have stopped the car right in the middle of Nevada and refused to keep going.
I suppose ignorance is bliss, because I kept that car pointed straight ahead with great enthusiasm for the unknown, and began the typical life of a faithful Mormon at BYU. I’ve always put my best effort into what I believed to be true, and I’ve always pushed myself to travel to uncomfortable places. It’s been a combination of bumpy and smooth, twisted and straight, stormy and sunny and somehow I’ve managed to keep traveling, stopping to pick up truth and leaving baggage along the way.
As I sit in my sister-in-law’s ward for Sacrament Meeting in Orem, Utah and hear the speaker testify that Satan is real – he is out in the world and we must hold fast to our faith and our testimonies without questioning and doubting, or we will fall into a place of delusion and great unhappiness — I know she’s wrong. As well-intentioned as she is, speaking from her heart — I know that her beliefs come from a life-journey that hasn’t taken her there yet. For whatever reason, she hasn’t needed to go there — to a place of challenging that specific belief, and hasn’t had a life experience to prove otherwise to her (yet).
This leaves me wondering — where will my life journey take me to next? Is there a symbolic zion, a nirvana, a place of seeing things clearly while living within a human framework? Is it accessible to me? Twenty years from now, if I’m fortunate enough to be alive on this earth, what delusions that I presently hold will I be able to see clearly? Will I have a reason to make the drive across Nevada again, and will it be in a Honda that isn’t reliant on fossil fuels, and will I end up in Tinkerbell’s world once more, reliving this very moment through new eyes? And will I ever learn to create sentences that don’t run-on or begin with prepositions? Where will I be in my belief system and will I ever stop asking so many damn questions?
;
;
I love this, Laurie.
Yesterday while we were out and about, Kennedy saw a group of people with all kinds of tattoos. I’ll just say it here and people can string me up later: I’m not a tattoo fan, so she’s probably picked that up from me. She pointed the people out and said, “I will never marry a man with tattoos.” I chuckled and said, “Kennedy, careful with such declarations. You never know what you might think in 5 years.” ;)
Your post reminded me of this. Sometimes we’re so sure of our convictions, it’s shocking to look back after a change of heart/position/opinion and remember the very-different-person that we were. That realization should help us be more humble and more tentative about our beliefs/opinions, no? In some ways, I have felt that tentativeness. But with other things, I’m still quite pig-headed. Not willing to entertain alternative viewpoints. Sigh . . .
“I know she’s wrong. As well-intentioned as she is, speaking from her heart — I know that her beliefs come from a life-journey that hasn’t taken her there yet. For whatever reason, she hasn’t needed to go there — to a place of challenging that specific belief, and hasn’t had a life experience to prove otherwise to her (yet).”
Is it possible that she has indeed been to a place of challenging specific beliefs, and she just came to a different place than you?
“As I sit in my sister-in-law’s ward for Sacrament Meeting in Orem, Utah and hear the speaker testify that Satan is real — he is out in the world and we must hold fast to our faith and our testimonies without questioning and doubting, or we will fall into a place of delusion and great unhappiness — I know she’s wrong. As well-intentioned as she is, speaking from her heart — I know that her beliefs come from a life-journey that hasn’t taken her there yet. For whatever reason, she hasn’t needed to go there — to a place of challenging that specific belief, and hasn’t had a life experience to prove otherwise to her (yet).”
I thought this was a great way to put it.
I’ve always thought that a snapshot into the future would make life struggles easier to bear, particularly when I just want the things I want NOW. But this post makes me realize otherwise. It might have scared the pants off you to see yourself as Buddhist that long ago, what you wouldn’t have been able to see was how okay you are with where you’ve been and where you’re going.
Beautiful post! Brought tears to my eyes. I especially loved the TInkerbell reference. You never know what life is going to throw your way. Each person is a walking book, a NY TImes bestseller list book :)
Wow! What an piece of art in writing, you express your experience so eloquently! Some people just have that talent, and you are certainly one of them. And not to mention the insight you provide….I think so many of us can relate to the amount of unexpected surprises we encounter in life; nevertheless, I am grateful for them all and would trade them not as I learned something from every one and know I will continue to do so from what ever I encounter in the future.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately. How life surprises you, how people come in and out of your life at unexpected and blessed moments. How so much is different about me, but also the same. Love this post.
I like to look forward and backwards at life… however, I feel more and more like a completely different version of myself than I was ten years ago, whereas when I was younger, there was much more of a single, unified ‘me’ that I could track and identify. I think I’m coming to embrace the turns of the river, and the development that this allows. If I had clung too much to the ‘me’ I thought I knew, I wouldn’t have been able to develop as much as I feel I have.
I still like the words from the hymn ‘Lead, Kindly Light’ (which was sung at my Grandma’s funeral last week):
‘Keep thou my feet, I do not ask to see/ The distant scene: one step enough for me.’
Not in a sense of ignorance or lack of curiosity – but a faith in stepping forward, and in the good that will come of that.
Thanks for this post, Mel! You’ve travelled over some rough ground: but along a good trail.
Love that hymn, Andy.